Fuzzy on the Law: Are eight-liner gaming machines unconstitutional?

by | May 12, 2022 | Regulatory Risk Analysis and Compliance

The legality of electronic gaming machines known as “eight-liners” has been debated in Texas for years. Although gambling devices are generally prohibited, eight-liner owners have taken the position that their machines fall within the so-called “fuzzy-animal exception.” In March 2022, a Texas court of appeals held that eight-liners are lotteries and can’t be lawfully operated without a constitutional amendment. Does this mean the end of eight-liners in Texas?

Gambling has been prohibited in Texas for most of the state’s history. Over time, the Texas Constitution has been amended to allow charitable bingo, charitable raffles, and a state-operated lottery. Horse and dog racing (pari-mutuel) was legalized by a statewide referendum.

Eight-liners have not been legalized by constitutional amendment or statewide referendum. The Penal Code prohibits gambling devices that, for consideration, allow the player an opportunity to win anything of value. However, there is an exception—known as the fuzzy-animal exception—that allows operators to award noncash prizes that are worth $5 or less.[1] The legislature’s goal was to “clear up a gray area in the law by exempting bona fide amusement games such as the kind that allow persons to use skill to win fuzzy animals.”[2]

Soon after, eight-liner owners began taking the position that their machines fall within the fuzzy-animal exception. Depending on how the eight-liner awards prizes, that argument has succeeded or failed in varying measures.[3]

A few years after the legislature adopted the fuzzy-animal exception, Texas Attorney General Dan Morales issued an opinion agreeing that the exception is unconstitutional “because it contravenes the Texas Constitution’s proscription of ‘lotteries.’”[4] About ten years later, then-Attorney General Greg Abbott reaffirmed that conclusion.[5] The Texas Supreme Court has never addressed the issue, allowing the legal dispute over whether the exception covers particular variations of eight-liners to continue.

Texas State Representative Richard Raymond (D-Laredo) has filed legislation in the last seven sessions, proposing a constitutional amendment to authorize local option elections to legalize or prohibit the operation of eight-liners and similar gaming devices. The legislation has never gained traction, left pending in committee each session.[6]

In 2017 and again in 2019, Texas Senator Bob Hall (R-Edgewood) proposed legislation to include eight-liners in the Penal Code’s definition of “gambling devices,” thus making it illegal to play and bet for money or other thing of value on an eight-liner. The bills died in committee without receiving a hearing.

Regulation by counties

Some counties in Texas have taken matters into their own hands.  In 2013, the Texas Legislature amended the Local Government Code to give certain Texas counties the authority to regulate the operation of game rooms.[7] The law was amended in 2019 to expand that right to all Texas counties. The Local Government Code doesn’t authorize municipalities to regulate game rooms (but apparently that didn’t stop Bridge City, Texas from doing so).

For example, in April 2022, the Llano County Commissioners Court adopted an ordinance regulating game rooms with six or more eight-liners or other amusement redemption machines. Under the new Llano County ordinance:

  • A permit is required to operate a game room. The initial fee for a new game room permit is $1,000, and the annual renewal fee is $1,000.
  • Existing game rooms are given a 30 day grace period to submit a permit application.
  • No permit is required to operate a children’s arcade, a small arcade in a legitimate movie theatre, or a business where 51% or more of revenues are derived from food and beverage sales and the gaming machines are secondary.
  • No game room can open within 2,500 feet of a public or private school, place of worship, residential neighborhood, land where a residential neighborhood is planned, or another game room. Those already in operation are grandfathered in.
  • Game rooms cannot require memberships to play.
  • Game rooms cannot lock their doors during business hours.
  • No game room can operate between 10 p.m. and 8 a.m.
  • A violation of the ordinance, including operating without a permit, is a Class A misdemeanor.

Blanco County, Caldwell County, and Orange County, among others, have adopted similar ordinances. Although the Local Government Code authorizes counties to regulate game rooms, those provisions do not legalize any activity prohibited under the Penal Code or other state law.

City of Fort Worth v. Rylie

Whether eight-liners are illegal gambling devices may eventually be decided by the Texas Supreme Court.

The Fort Worth Court of Appeals made news in March 2022 when it issued its opinion in City of Fort Worth v. Rylie, a case challenging the city’s game room regulations.[8]

In 2014, responding to what it perceived as the “deleterious effects [of game rooms] on the community,” the Fort Worth City Council passed ordinances designed to rein in the proliferation of such establishments. Operators of eight-liner game rooms challenged the ordinances, and the city counterclaimed for a declaration that the Penal Code’s fuzzy-animal exception is unconstitutional.

The Fourth Court of Appeals held that that eight-liners are lotteries, because they involve the three elements of a lottery: chance, prize, and consideration. Because eight-liners are lotteries, they cannot be lawfully operated without an amendment to the Texas Constitution. “Even with the best of intentions,” the court said in its opinion, “the legislature cannot sanction a lottery of any type; a constitutional amendment is necessary.” The court of appeals declined to reach the fuzzy-animal exception’s applicability or constitutionality.

The plaintiff game room operators have indicated they will file a motion for rehearing en banc in the court of appeals. The case could eventually make its way back to the Texas Supreme Court (it’s been there once already, but the court remanded, specifically directing the court of appeals to decide whether eight-liners are constitutional and legal).[9] Until voters approve a constitutional amendment, or a case makes its way to the Texas Supreme Court, eight-liner gaming rooms will operate on precarious legal footing.

[1] See Tex. Pen. Code §§ 47.01-47.02.

[2] City of Fort Worth v. Rylie, No. 02-17-00185-CV, 2022 WL 803842, at *4 (Tex. App.—Fort Worth Mar. 17, 2022, no pet. h.).

[3] Rylie, No. 02-17-00185-CV, 2022 WL 803842, at *5.

[4] Op. Tex. Att’y Gen. No. DM-466 (1998).

[5] Op. Tex. Att’y Gen. No. GA-0527 (2007).

[6] HJR 37 (2021); HJR 18 (2019); HJR 23 (2017); HJR 92 (2015); HJR 27 (2013); HJR 41 (2011); HJR 79 (2009).

[7] 2013 Tex. Sess. Law Serv. Ch. 1284 (HB 2123) (codified at Tex. Loc. Gov’t Code §§ 234.131-234.140).

[8] Rylie, No. 02-17-00185-CV, 2022 WL 803842.

[9] City of Fort Worth v. Rylie, 602 S.W.3d 459 (Tex. 2020).

Subscribe to the Texas Government Law Blog

* indicates required